|
Documentation
Center of Cambodia
2005 Work Plan
We expect that 2005 will be an extremely
eventful year for the Documentation Center of Cambodia (DC-Cam) with the Khmer
Rouge tribunal approaching. On October 4 and 5, 2004 Cambodia’s new National
Assembly ratified: 1) The Agreement between the United Nations and the Royal
Government of Cambodia concerning the Prosecution under Cambodian Law of Crimes
Committed during the period of Democratic Kampuchea, and 2) The Law on
Amendments to the Law on the Extraordinary Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia
for the Prosecution of Crimes Committed during the Period of Democratic
Kampuchea.
On October 27, the head of state promulgated a law (the Khmer Rouge Tribunal
Law) that harmonizes the government’s agreement with the UN on establishing the
tribunal.
The Cambodian people have waited for over a
quarter of a century to see the regime’s senior leaders held accountable for
their actions and justice done. The impending tribunal has been a focus of our
work this year, and will continue to inform our activities throughout 2005. We
are very optimistic about our ability to succeed in our planned endeavors and
thus contribute to the promotion of memory and justice in Cambodia.
The coming year should witness both
significant continuity and change at DC-Cam. Some of our projects will continue
with comparatively minor amendments in 2005, but others will undergo
modification or increase dramatically in scope and pace. In addition, we plan to
implement innovative projects to prepare Cambodian citizens for the trials, to
increase public participation in the tribunal process itself, and to educate the
younger generations of Cambodians on their modern history.
Below we summarize our main accomplishments
during 2004 and our plans to take our projects forward. We also briefly describe
projects we will begin implementing next year. The following sections provide a
more detailed overview of our 2004 activities and plans for 2005 in each of our
major areas of operation.
Project |
2004
Activities |
2005
Plans |
Documentation |
Cataloguing
and
Database
Management |
13,512
documents catalogued
7,056
documents keyed |
17,000
catalogued
31,000
keyed
DC-Cam
genocide database established |
Microfilming |
29,025
pages filmed |
25,000
documents filmed |
Access
Listing |
5,000
documents |
4,480
documents
Develop
film at DC-Cam |
Photo
Exhibitions |
Forensic
exhibition |
1 or more
new exhibits |
Other
Exhibitions |
Supplied
materials to 3 museums |
Friedrich
Ebert Stiftung Foundation (Germany) exhibit |
Digital
Photo Archives |
Produced
book, catalogued and posted 180+ photographs |
Possible
second monograph |
Film |
30-minute
documentary produced and selected for the Brussels Film
Festival |
|
Promoting
Accountability and the Rule of Law |
Mapping |
Project
formally completed; 450-page report produced |
Master GIS
database to be completed |
Forensics
Study |
Mass grave
reconnaissance |
Monograph |
Accountability |
660
interviews (estimated)
Work
completed in 4 provinces
2,000
interviews analyzed |
1,050
interviews
Expansion
to 5 new provinces
Legal
analysis of interviews |
Tribunal
Support |
Procedures
developed for access to DC-Cam archives
Public
Information Room opened; hosts 500+ visitors
DC-Cam
office opened at Rutgers University (US) |
Procedures
refined
Tribunal
Response Team formed
PIR “road
trips” taken to the provinces
Operations
of US office expanded |
Legal
Training |
30 people
given six weeks of legal training |
Defense
counsel legal training |
Public
Education and Outreach |
Victims of
Torture |
144 people
interviewed; 49 identified with post-traumatic stress disorder
(PTSD) |
186
interviews completed; 28 PTSD victims counseled |
Radio
|
Expanded
broadcasts to 2 additional provinces
In-house
studio completed |
Broadcasts
extended to 5 more provinces
Studio
produces pre-recorded programs for provinces |
Website |
180+
photographs posted
Redesign
begins |
Redesign
completed
Chat room
set up
Cham
Muslim website set up |
Pre-Trial
Outreach |
Cham oral
history and website, Buddhist nun march, and student canvassing
planned
|
Cham, nun,
and student projects implemented |
Living
Documents |
-- |
1,200
people from rural areas nationwide attend the tribunal, hold village
forums, and are filmed for showings at other villages (3-year
project) |
Genocide
Education |
-- |
Information
collected on current education on DK in Cambodia and other countries,
curricula, films, museums, etc., in preparation for the development of
curricula and text in 2006 |
Cross-Border
Cooperation |
DC-Cam
provides assistance to NGOs in Iraq, Thailand, Serbia, and former
Yugoslavia |
Proposed
affinity group of documentation centers to solve strategic and technical
issues
Host 2 or
more interns from Burma |
Research,
Publications, and Translation |
Magazine |
84,000
Khmer and 2,800 English issues published and distributed
400+
government booklets on the tribunal distributed
Requests
(e.g., family tracing) jump dramatically |
Increased
print runs of the Khmer editions should funding be available
Possible
production of a quarterly magazine for the Cham Muslim
community |
Research
and Writing |
3
monographs published
Research
assistance provided on 8 books by foreign scholars |
4 or more
monographs published
Additional
research assistance |
Translation |
Translations
of 3 books completed |
Translations
of at least 3 books completed |
Research
Forum |
Essay
contest held |
New essay
contest |
Media and
Academic Outreach |
At least
200 articles published by or on DC-Cam |
At least
as many articles published |
Personnel
and Resource Development |
Personnel |
7 staff
pursuing advanced degrees abroad
6 new
Cambodian and 4 international volunteers |
At least 3
additional staff study abroad
Increase
translation staff
Recruit 5
Cambodian and 3 international volunteers |
Resources |
Security
measures enhanced modestly
Fundraiser
recruited
Public
Information Room added |
Improve
security measures further
Contract
fundraiser
Acquire
land and facilities for a permanent center |
|
|
|
|
We have also note four areas in which
we did not meet our goals:
-
Databases/Server. Last year, we contracted
with a local company (Khmer Hosting) to make our databases publicly available.
After nearly a year had passed, the company told us that it did not have the
technical capabilities to complete this work, although the company is still
working to complete the database. We have now made arrangements with an IT
expert to design the database. DC-Cam staff will enter the data and the
database should be completed by June 2005
-
NGO Cooperation. Although we are currently working with a
number of local non-government organizations, we did not increase our
participation in this area as much as planned. We have sent staff
representatives to nearly all of the NGO meetings we have been asked to
attend, but other staff commitments have precluded our direct involvement in
many NGO umbrella groups and projects. For 2005, we plan to target the most
promising of these projects and second staff to them; we will also work to
include appropriate NGOs in one or more of the Center’s projects.
-
Website Posting.
We had planned to complete the posting of
our most important documents on the DC-Cam website in 2004, and this target
has not been met. However, in October, a volunteer from the Netherlands (Isaac
Tabor) joined us for seven months. He has begun the reorganization and
re-design of our website, and has made good progress in posting up large
numbers of documents and photographs. We expect to have the site up to date
before he returns home in April
2005.
-
Staff Development. With many of our most senior staff on
academic leave, our staff now working at the Center have less experience and
require closer supervision, resulting in slower progress on many projects. It
has also increased the amount of time DC-Cam’s management must devote to staff
supervision and development. This situation will begin to ease slightly with
the return of a few senior staff next year.
1.
Documentation
Documenting the history of the Khmer Rouge
is at the core of our operations: it is an important part of our center’s
mandate and plays a major role in all our projects. DC-Cam has been active in
collecting documents relevant to the history of the Democratic Kampuchea (DK)
era for nearly a decade. To date, we have amassed well over 600,000 pages of
documentation from the DK-era, petitions and interview transcripts taken from
survivors of the regime, and a variety of other materials that could potentially
serve as evidence at the tribunal. DC-Cam by no means
possesses a monopoly on documentation relevant to the crimes of Communist Party
of Kampuchea (CPK) leaders, but it is the largest repository of such materials.
1.1
Cataloguing and Database Management
The first aspect of our documentation work
entails collecting and cataloguing documents and managing two major databases,
the Cambodian Genocide Bibliographic Database (CBIB) and the Cambodian Genocide
Biographical Database (CBIO). Set up in collaboration with Yale University and the University of New South
Wales, these databases contain detailed information on former Khmer Rouge
leaders and cadres. They provide an organized information resource about the DK
regime and many of its victims. The databases also facilitate our program of
family tracing, whereby survivors of the DK era can search for information on
lost loved ones. Because these databases are Internet accessible and available
on CD-Rom and microfilm, scholars, legal personnel for the tribunal (both the
prosecution and defense) and the general public in Cambodia and abroad can
access them.
Cataloguing and Keying.
Since DC-Cam began operating in 1995, we
have catalogued (entered information into worksheets in preparation for adding
them to our databases) or keyed (entered information into the databases) nearly
83,000 documents, which are housed in six collections:
-
D Collection: General Khmer Rouge documents (e.g.,
notebooks, biographies, confessions, reports, execution logs) and the Anlong
Veng (a KR stronghold until 1996) collection of post-KR materials (e.g.,
school textbooks, meeting minutes, reports).
-
I Collection: Biographies of Khmer Rouge cadres and
prisoners.
-
J Collection: Confessions from S-21 (Tuol Sleng)
prison.
-
K Collection: Biographies of Khmer Rouge cadres and
prisoners.
-
L Collection: Intelligence documents from the Lon Nol
regime (1970-1975).
-
R Collection: Petitions to the Peoples Republic of
Kampuchea (the government that held power from 1979 to 1993) to oust the Khmer
Rouge from their seat at the United Nations, including accounts of horrific
crimes and descriptions of mass burial pits and prisons.
Documents |
To
Date |
Status |
D
Collection |
Catalogued |
15,730 |
The
remaining 8,333 documents will be catalogued in 2005 |
Keyed in
Khmer |
4,367 |
14,058 of
the remaining 19,696 worksheets will be keyed in 2005 |
Keyed in
English |
2,649 |
16,992 of
the remaining 21,414 worksheets will be keyed in 2005
|
I
Collection |
Catalogued |
10,683 |
Completed |
Keyed in
Khmer |
10,683 |
Completed |
Keyed in
English |
10,683 |
Completed |
J
Collection |
Catalogued |
913 |
Completed |
Keyed in
Khmer |
913 |
Completed |
Keyed in
English |
913 |
Completed |
K
Collection |
Catalogued |
9,341 |
Completed |
Keyed in
Khmer |
9,341 |
Completed |
Keyed in
English |
9,341 |
Completed |
L
Collection |
Catalogued |
7,820 |
7,820
documents to be completed in 2005 |
Keyed in
Khmer |
-- |
To be
completed post-2005 |
Keyed in
English |
-- |
To be
completed post-2005 |
R
Collection |
Catalogued |
701 |
1,699 of
the remaining 2,400 documents
will be
catalogued in 2005 |
Keyed in
Khmer |
-- |
To be
completed post-2005 |
Keyed in
English |
-- |
To be
completed post-2005 |
Total
catalogued |
45,188 |
Total
keyed |
37,773 |
In 2005, we have planned to catalogue 17,852
documents and key 31,050 documents. To accomplish this and meet our ambitious
goal of having all of our documents catalogued before the trials begin, we will
hire additional staff.
In 2005, we also have plans to consolidate
all of the information in our archives into a genocide database in 2005 that
DC-Cam is now developing (tentatively called the Khmer Rouge History Database).
We will employ Microsoft Access or a similar user-friendly format that will
enable quick and accurate searches.
Indexing.
In 2003, we began to prepare a hard-copy
index of biographical information on nearly 11,000 Khmer Rouge contained in our
CBIO database. This index will contain information on each individual’s name,
alias, gender, place of birth, rank/position, and record number. In 2004, we
decided to add a record of each person’s status (alive, executed, disappeared)
based on interviews our Accountability Project teams have conducted with the
relatives or neighbors of former Khmer Rouge. By 2004, we had made corrections
to the 2,820-page Khmer version of the book and translated 250 pages; we plan to
complete another 960 pages in 2005. In addition, we will make an index of this
book available at our Public Information Room.
Access Listing. In 2004, we began entering our documents in
a user-friendly Microsoft Access list. This list provides basic bibliographical
information in English and Khmer. To date, we have listed about 5,000 documents
from our D collection and plan to enter an additional 4,480 documents in
2005.
Website Posting. In 2004, we contracted with a local company
to increase our storage space on the Internet, provide a range of ongoing
technical services, and assist us in updating and expanding our website. A main
goal of this effort was to post searchable databases on the Internet, thus
enabling us to share more of our documentation work with scholars and interested
members of the public. However, we canceled our contract with the company when
it failed to perform.
Realizing the importance of posting our
documents, we will continue searching for a company that can assist us in
loading our databases onto DC-Cam’s website. In the interim, we will work to
secure other means that will enable the public to access our materials.
Preservation. We have preserved all of the original
documents we hold from DK in non-acidic Mylar plastic. They are stored in
locked, fireproof safes.
1.2
Microfilming
This project aims to preserve historical
documents related to the Khmer Rouge. It gives researchers and legal
investigators access to our archival information without handling original
documents, many of which have become fragile with age.
To date, we have microfilmed all of the
documents in our I, J, K, and L collections, with only part of our D and R
collections remaining. In 2005, we plan to microfilm over 25,000 documents from
these latter two collections.
|
Reels/Pages
Microfilmed
to
Date |
Reels/Pages
to be Microfilmed in 2005 |
D
Collection |
235/176,406 |
all will
be completed by December 2005 |
R
Collection |
17/12,136 |
all will
be completed by December 2005 |
PA
Interview Transcripts |
0/28,936 |
112/37,428 |
We have been cooperating with Yale
University’s Sterling Library since 1998 on duplicating our microfilm records
for security and academic purposes. We sent the negatives to the library to be
developed; they kept the masters and returned a copy to us. However, by the end
of the year, Yale had yet to process 77 of the 482 reels of film we sent to
them, some of which were over a year late in being returned to DC-Cam. Because
Yale had not fulfilled its latest contractual obligations to DC-Cam (the
deadline for their completion of the microfilm was December 31, 2004), we
decided to develop our microfilm in-house. (On January 12, 2005, Yale returned
the remaining microfilm copies to us, thus completing our R collection
documents).
Last year, we had microfilm developed at the
National Archives of Cambodia, but found that the product incompatible with our
quality standards. We thus concluded that the most cost-efficient option
consistent with our quality demands was to acquire our own microfilm
developer/duplicator. We purchased this equipment and it was recently delivered
to us. During the last two weeks of December, we developed 8 reels (5,799
pages). These files will be posted on our website in 2005. We will also store
duplicates of our microfilm at secure locations inside Cambodia.
1.3
Photo Exhibitions
Exhibitions in Cambodia.
Two of the photo exhibitions we installed
during 2003 at the Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum (one on former Khmer
Rouge cadres during DK and today, and the other on the regime’s top leaders)
continue to be displayed and receive favorable comments from Cambodian and
international visitors alike.
From the UK:
“Seeing is believing, to remember and never forget. Why should this
happen, again and again? Will there ever be a last time? Will we ever
learn? Rest in peace forever, all you innocent people. I will carry this
visit with me always.”
From Brazil: “An exhibition like this
is an excellent way to make sure history does not repeat itself. Let’s
make sure it does not happen anywhere else in the world.”
From Cambodia: “After I visited Tuol
Sleng and saw the photos exhibited, I still don’t understand the purpose
of Pol Pot, and that Khmers killed their own people. So, the only way to
give peace to the victims is to try the surviving Khmer Rouge
leaders.” |
In 2004, we mounted a new forensic
exhibition at Tuol Sleng. It contains photographs of 10 skulls excavated from
Choeung Ek (the “killing fields” south of Phnom Penh where Tuol Sleng prisoners
were executed) and other parts of Cambodia, accompanied by text explaining the
type of trauma to each skull. This exhibit seeks to demonstrate the value of
forensic evidence in documenting the Khmer Rouge’s crimes against humanity. It
is also intended to educate the public about the types of information that can
be scientifically gathered from victims’ remains in order to prove and record
evidence of murder/genocide. (Because some Cambodians are uncomfortable with the
idea of boxing human remains, we house the skulls in a separate room at Tuol
Sleng, which is open only to officials.)
From Australia: “May the work carried
out here play a positive role in bringing the perpetrators of these
inhuman crimes to justice. Seeing the exhibit gives me a sense of shame,
that I can be part of a species that does this to itself, but also hope,
in the smiles of Cambodians and their determination to keep on surviving.
This must never be forgotten and it must never happen
again.” |
In response to recent articles (e.g.,
“Cambodia-Khmer Rouge Museum: Upset Over Renovations at Cambodia’s Infamous
Khmer Rouge Torture Prison,” AFP, November 11, 2004), DC-Cam has received
letters from Democratic Kampuchea survivors, historians, and museum specialists
around the world expressing dismay at the prison’s recent renovation work,
including a new paint job. It is DC-Cam’s position that the studies performed at
Tuol Sleng to date are not sufficient to serve as the basis for an effective
renovation plan. Instead, architects and engineers should be commissioned to
perform a detailed study of structural weaknesses before further modifications
are made. We will continue to press for preserving as much of Tuol Sleng’s
historical structures as possible while undertaking the necessary work to keep
the buildings sound and safe for the public.
Other Worldwide Exhibits.
In 2004, we supplied the Washington State
Genocide Museum, the Chicago Killing Fields Museum, the new Rwanda Genocide
Museum, and several individuals with photographs that have been used in
exhibitions (nearly the entire collection of the Washington facility, which is
the first Cambodian genocide museum in the United States, was provided
by
DC-Cam).
In 2005, we will work with Germany’s
Friedrich Ebert Stiftung Foundation to contribute photographs for an exhibit at
its headquarters next year. The exhibit, whose working title is “The Trauma of
Terror and the Challenges of Coming to Terms with the Past,” will be followed by
a symposium. DC-Cam staff and Taing Kim will attend the symposium and screen
The Khmer Rouge Rice Fields for those attending (please see Section
1.5).
1.4
The Digital Photo Archive Project
DC-Cam interviewed over 100 former Khmer
Rouge cadre and their family members, and obtained nearly 200 photographs from
the DK era. A monograph on the recollections of former cadres and their families
(the base people) entitled Stilled Lives: Photographs from the Cambodian
Genocide, is now at the printing house. We also scanned all of the
photographs, captioned and indexed them, and are placing them and other project
information on the Internet. The project team also received training on book
design and layout in India.
We have hope to produce a second book next
year that focuses on the new people. These were city dwellers who were either
executed (e.g., members of the former Lon Nol regime) or evacuated to Cambodia’s provinces during DK and forced into hard
labor.
1.5
Film
Project
In 2004, DC-Cam provided research,
translation, and other support to Cambodian director Rithy Panh on his
documentary S-21: The Khmer Rouge Killing Machine, which was screened at
the Cannes Film Festival. In April, DC-Cam director Youk Chhang accompanied Mr.
Panh to New York to screen the film at the United Nations in preface to
fundraising at the tribunal. We also gave advisory support to Mr. Panh two other
documentary films.
This year, DC-Cam also produced its first
film, a 30-minute documentary entitled The Khmer Rouge Rice Fields: The Story
of Rape Survivor Taing Kim. It is about the gang rape of a woman by Khmer
Rouge soldiers and her views on justice and reconciliation. The film is being
shown at DC-Cam’s Public Information Room and daily at Tuol Sleng. It has been
screened at five locations in Thailand, and will show in November at the
Brussels Film Festival and Prix Bruno Mersch, and the Asian Cultural Council in
New York in December. DVD productions of the film have earned $400, which is
being used to support the education of Taing Kim’s children.
1.6
Collection of New Materials and Data
Although we possess a very large collection
of documentary materials, we are always on the lookout for additional
acquisitions. In 2004, we will continue to search for new documentary materials
in Cambodia and abroad from both institutional sources and individuals. In
October, DC-Cam’s director traveled to Hanoi to determine the status of the
large number of DK-era documents held by the Vietnamese government.
2.
Promoting
Accountability and the Rule of Law
We do not expect that legal accountability
for the horrific crimes of the Khmer Rouge will completely resolve the problems
of poverty and injustice Cambodians face today. However, the leaders’
prosecution in a court of law will be the most important factor in helping
victims realize some measure of justice for the wrongs committed against them
and their loved ones, and then begin to reach closure with the past. Just as
important, the process of accountability for the Khmer Rouge must serve as a
bridge toward a stronger rule of law.
Important steps toward accountability were
achieved in October 2004, when Cambodia ratified its agreement with the United
Nations on the tribunal of senior Khmer Rouge leaders, promulgated the Khmer
Rouge Tribunal Law that harmonizes the agreement, and passed amendments to the
law after a yearlong political deadlock that followed the country’s general
election in July 2003. In 2004, DC-Cam continued or initiated a number of
activities to support the trials of senior Khmer Rouge officials and will
continue these activities in 2005.
2.1
The Mapping Project
This project, which began in 1995, involved
seeking out and mapping mass graves, former DK prisons, and genocide memorials
using Geographic Information System (GIS) technology. Sometimes, the readers of
our magazine also send us information on the locations of prisons and graves (in
November, for example, a Cambodian expatriate wrote us to say he was the only
one of 450 Lon Nol soldiers to survive a prison camp in Preik Datch near Neak
Loeung along the Mekong River; DC-Cam was unaware of its existence).
Our mapping team identified 19,521 mass graves
in 391 clusters, 194 Khmer Rouge security offices, and 80 memorials constructed
by survivors of the DK regime. In addition, in 2004, we wrote a 450-page field
report on this project with 180 photographs. Although the project formally
closed this year, we are continuing to enter its master data set into our GIS
database, and will post the data set on our website in 2005.
2.2
The Forensics Study
Based on existing mapping data, a team of
three North American research and forensics experts and DC-Cam’s mapping team
conducted a detailed reconnaissance of mass graves and memorials to identify
sites for a full-scale forensic exhumation. In 2004, we mounted a forensic
exhibition of human skeletal remains at the Tuol Sleng Museum and produced a
project report on undisturbed graves in two Cambodian villages. Portions of the
exhibit can now be viewed on our website. One of the North American experts
hired for the project will complete a monograph on forensic findings and crimes
against humanity in Cambodia in 2005.
2.3
Accountability Project (PA)
Our PA Project focuses on fact-finding in
advance of the tribunal and seeks to build a better historical understanding of
the workings of the DK regime. One of our main activities in this vein is to
draw a picture of subordinate-superior relationships during DK and to identify
survivors (victims and former Khmer Rouge) who may be helpful in the tribunal.
With the tribunal drawing near, we will accelerate the pace and expand the scope
of this project.
Interviews and Database.
In 2004, as in previous years, our main
activity was to conduct interviews with former Khmer Rouge cadres in the field.
Using information from our files, our team locates and interviews individuals
who served in the DK regime. Our normal procedure is to identify and investigate
all relevant biographies from a given geographic area (see our description of
the CBIO above). We conducted this work through field offices in Kandal, Takeo,
Kampong Cham and Kampot provinces. In the first three quarters of 2004, we
completed 495 interviews in the field, with an estimated 660 interviews
anticipated for this calendar year.
In 2005, we plan to interview 1,050 victims
and former Khmer Rouge. Since our work has been completed in the first four
provinces, the project will operate in Kampong Thom, Kampong Chhnang, Kampong
Speu, Pursat, and Prey Veng provinces in 2005. We also plan to add staff to our
PA Project in order to complete the large amount of field work required. We will
also continue to enter information about interviewees into our database, which
provides the names, whereabouts, and basic biographical information about each
of the former cadres we interview. This database is likely to be very important
to prosecutors in the tribunal proceedings.
Activity |
To
Date |
2005
Plan |
Biographies
investigated* |
4,310
(est. by year end 2004) |
2,592 of
the remaining 15,714 biographies to be investigated |
Survivors
(victims/perpetrators) interviewed |
1,509/429*
(28,936 pages)
(by
3rd quarter 2004) |
800/250 of
the remaining 5,502/1,564 will be interviewed |
Records
entered into the Accountability Database |
2,595 |
2,400 of
the 6,902 remaining records will be entered
|
* Many of those
whose biographies are investigated have disappeared. However, we have found that
when investigating a man or woman who disappeared, villagers are apt to talk
more openly about him or her than they would their own family members; this has
proven to be an invaluable source of information for our staff.
Analysis of Data.
In 2004, we began a major new activity with
Dr. Stephen Heder of the School of Oriental and African Studies at the
University of London, who is one of the world’s leading experts on modern
Cambodian history. To date, Dr. Heder has analyzed nearly 2,000 interviews
(30,000 pages) we have conducted with Khmer Rouge cadres. Specifically, he will
determine if the interviews provide information relevant to the cases of the
former Khmer Rouge officials most likely to stand trial. Dr. Heder is providing
English summaries of the historically salient points in selected interviews,
while preparing the materials for legal analysis and presentation to the
Extraordinary Chambers. In addition, he accompanied our field teams to conduct
several follow-up interviews with cadres who may be important in providing
indications of the leadership chain of the Khmer Rouge. We anticipate that his
analysis will be completed in December 2004.
In 2005, DC-Cam’s legal advisor, John D.
Ciorciari, will conduct a legal analysis of the translated interviews with
DC-Cam’s support. Dr. Ciorciari is former Wai Seng Senior Research Scholar at
Oxford University and a Harvard- and Oxford-educated lawyer.
2.4
General Support for the Khmer Rouge Tribunal
As the UN and Cambodian government prepare
for trials of certain former Khmer Rouge officials, we have been preparing to
support the tribunal. Our activities include:
Procedures for Access to DC-Cam’s Archives.
To provide the court and
other authorized officials with full access to our documents, we have worked
with our legal advisors and sought the advice of legal experts from the
International Criminal Tribunal for Yugoslavia (ICTY) to develop and issue rules
and guidelines for accessing them during the tribunal process. They are designed
to ensure that our documents remain available for review and as secure as
possible. We have provided a copy of the procedures to the appropriate UN and
Cambodian authorities.
As the tribunal process unfolds in 2005, we
will develop an even more specific set of guidelines to ensure that we assist
the proceedings as effectively as possible.
Tribunal Response Team.
We began planning for this team in late
2003. In 2004, we have added more detail to the plan, which we hope to implement
in 2005 (depending on funding for the tribunal). The team would comprise
Cambodian and non-Cambodian lawyers and political scientists/historians., two of
whom would work full time and would be assisted by shorter- term personnel on an
as-needed basis; they would be supervised by a DC-Cam staff member familiar with
our Center’s documentary holdings. This independent and neutral team will be in
a position to help tribunal and authorized officials (as well as the public)
carry out research and documentary reviews as needed. Also, Center staff will
translate additional documents into English in advance of the
tribunal.
In addition, we are seeking support to bring
one or more experts from within Cambodia or overseas (e.g., historians, document
preservationists) to Phnom Penh to work closely with our team before and during
the tribunal. We anticipate that we will seek the services of these experts
during 2005.
Public Information Room.
To meet the need for documentation materials
at the tribunal and dramatically increase access to our archival holdings,
DC-Cam opened its new Public Information Room (PIR) in late April 2004. Access
is given to legal personnel (representing both the defense and prosecution),
scholars, reporters, and the general public. The PIR is also home to DC-Cam’s
Victims of Torture Project and will house our Tribunal Response Team.
The PIR also functions as a library and
educational forum. To date, it has received over 500 visitors, hosted 9 guest
lectures, and screened 4 films on the regime (a total of 39 times). Recently,
the number of people coming to the PIR requesting information on atrocities
during DK has jumped from 1 or 2 per month to over 40.
|
2nd
Quarter 2004 |
3rd
Quarter 2004 |
Number of
Visitors |
100 |
427 |
In the past few months, DC-Cam has brought
together and met with hundreds of Cham Muslim leaders from throughout the
country, Buddhist nuns, and representatives of youth organizations, and held
talks/planning sessions with them in the PIR (Section 3.4). It also provided the
venue for our legal training course (Section 2.5).
For 2005, we plan to bring the PIR to the
provinces via “road trips” to rural areas where access to newspapers, television
and other means of communicating news is more difficult. Our activities will
include showing relevant films on the Khmer Rouge regime, presenting videos we
take of the trial process (assuming the tribunals have begun then), and hosting
informative talks about the tribunal in villages nationwide. In Phnom Penh, we will host public lectures at least
monthly and show films weekly on topics relevant to DK. Our plans will be
formalized as the tribunal process takes shape.
DC-Cam Overseas Office.
In 2004, we set up an office in the United
States at Rutgers University to collect and disseminate information on Khmer
Rouge history, with a particular emphasis on assisting the Cambodian North
American community. This office will also:
-
Serve as a reciprocal exchange between
DC-Cam and Rutgers students and faculty
-
Facilitate internships/externships at
DC-Cam for Rutgers students
-
Present research and training
opportunities for Rutgers students and faculty
-
Provide a venue for exhibitions,
conferences, and seminars
-
Locate information for and provide
translations to personnel from the UN, members of the legal community,
scholars, and others interested in the upcoming tribunal.
Two Rutgers graduate students from DC-Cam
(Meng-Try Ea and Vannak Huy) are staffing this office on a volunteer basis. We
are receiving support from Rutgers to keep the office open for at least two
years.
2.5
Legal Training Project
A critical part of our work is to train
Cambodian leaders on human rights law and related subjects. In July and August,
we held a six-week legal training course on international humanitarian and
criminal law. It was attended by 30 law students, human rights NGO workers,
reporters, political representatives, lawyers, and selected DC-Cam staff. The
trainees’ institutions and project staff are listed below.
Trainees’
Institutions |
Trainers/Project
Staff |
§
Cambodian Center for Human
Rights
§
Cambodian Communication
Institute,
Royal University of
Phnom Penh
§
Cambodia’s
Women Crisis Center
§
Club of
Cambodian Journalists
§
Documentation
Center of Cambodia
§
Khmer
Institute of Democracy
§
Rice
Political Party
§
Royal
Academy of Cambodia
§ Royal
University of Law and
Economics
§
Royal
University of Phnom Penh |
§
John
Ciociari (supervisor)
§
Aubrey
Ardema, Santa Clara
University School of Law (coordinator
and
trainer)
§
Bunsou
Sour, DC-Cam (coordinator)
§
Sorya Sim,
DC-Cam (coordinator)
§
Noy
Sophary, DC Cam (coordinator)
§
Phan
Sochea, DC Cam (coordinator)
§
Julia M.
Fromholz, University
California,
Berkeley/Harvard
University
§
Katrina E.
Anderson, Seattle
University School of
Law
§ Kelly
Whitley, JD candidate,
University of Virginia
§ Stephen
Andrew Liang, Harvard
Law
School |
As part of the course, our trainers prepared a
short guide to the Khmer Rouge tribunal and a basic text introducing readers to
the main features of human rights law relevant to development and transitional
justice in Cambodia. It is now being edited and we anticipate it will be
published in 2005.
We are planning to hold another legal
training course in 2005. It will focus on the defense counsel. We are recruiting
at Harvard this month to find instructors and interns for this
course.
3. Public
Education and Outreach
DC-Cam is committed to expanding the range
of forums in which we disseminate information, educate the public, and help
Cambodians remember their past and reconcile with it. While we use a variety of
traditional approaches to reach people (e.g., radio, website, publications), we
are also embarking on two innovative projects to realize these goals, including
helping average citizens participate directly in the tribunals. In 2005, we will
also expand our cooperation with documentation centers and other organizations
overseas.
3.1
The Victims of Torture Project
We began this two-year project in late 2003
with the Transcultural Psychosocial Organization (TPO). It involves counseling
for people who suffered abuse under the DK regime (both victims and
perpetrators) and are traumatized today. Our primary role is to assist the TPO
in identifying subjects for care.
Our original plan was to work in
either Takeo or Kandal
province, both of which contain a large proportion of victims of the
Khmer Rouge. However, we
subsequently added the pilot area of Koh Sla in Chhouk district of Kampot
province to the project. The majority of survivors in this region were Khmer
Rouge soldiers. Because of the sensitivities involved with the population in Koh
Slah, our 2004 work concentrated on building residents’ trust through informal
conversations, the erection of community street signs, the distribution of
magazines, and radio broadcasts. As a result, the number of former Khmer Rouge
we have been able to interview has increased sharply, with 33 interviews
conducted in this quarter. Next year, we will expand our radio broadcasts to
include a talk show program targeted to Koh Slah. It will use the new booklet
produced by the government on the tribunal to inform people about the trial
process.
In early 2004 we completed comprehensive TPO
training on counseling and the identification of trauma victims, and produced a
questionnaire that we use in interviews to identify traumatized individuals. Of
the 144 people interviewed, we identified about one-third as victims of
post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and referred them to TPO for treatment and
counseling. In addition, our questionnaires obtain local perspectives on justice
and reconciliation. For the purposes of analytical trauma studies,
reconciliation, and history, we began transcribing interviews this quarter and
keying interview data into the CBIB database. Our preliminary findings are that
there is a lower incidence of PTSD among former Khmer Rouge soldiers/cadres and
a higher incidence among women (about twice as many women as men were identified
as suffering from PTSD).
Province |
Interviews |
Cassettes
Recorded |
Pages
Transcribed |
PTSD
Victims Identified |
Kandal |
44 |
77 |
1,243 |
23 |
Takeo |
60 |
113 |
1,483 |
21 |
Kampot |
40
|
71 |
849 |
5 |
Total |
144
|
261 |
3,575 |
49 |
DC-Cam staff members plan to complete 186
interviews for the project by August 2005. Despite staff shortages, TPO will
provide counseling and treatment to at least 28 PTSD victims next year by
counseling some family members in groups and choosing counseling candidates who
are situated close together. They will also work to recruit more psychologists
to their staff.
3.2
Radio Broadcasts
In 2004, we continued to read selected
articles from Searching for the Truth magazine on a local radio station,
Women’s Media Center FM 102, which reaches many of Cambodia’s provinces. We
produce a radio program on this station twice every week. To date, we have read
approximately 57 articles. In addition, our staff members have been guest
speakers on an FM 102-hosted talk show on the Khmer Rouge (a transcript of this
show was published in Rasmei Kampuchea Daily).
We also expanded our coverage to other
provinces, as shown below.
Station |
Time |
Coverage |
Start
date |
Status |
Womens
Media
Center
Phnom
Penh
FM
102 |
3:30-3:45
p.m.
Wednesday
Thursday |
First They
Killed My Father
Searching
for the Truth
Anne
Frank |
Oct.
2002
May
2003
July
2004
|
Completed
Ongoing
Ongoing |
Kampot
FM
93.25 |
7:00-7:30
a.m./p.m. daily |
First They
Killed My Father
Searching
for the Truth
Anne
Frank |
Jun.
2004
Aug.
2004
Aug.
2004 |
Completed
Ongoing
Ongoing |
Preah
Vihear
FM
99* |
7:00-7:30
a.m.
6:30-7:00
p.m.
daily |
First They
Killed My Father
Searching
for the Truth |
Aug.
2004
Aug.
2004 |
Ongoing
Ongoing |
* This station
also reaches parts of Oddar Meanchey, Ratanak Kiri, Stung Treng, and Kampong
Thom provinces.
For 2005, DC-Cam plans to expand its
broadcasts to Siem Reap, Kampong Cham, Sihanoukville, Battambang and Svay Rieng.
We will also explore various radio formats, such as forums or listener hotlines,
to encourage audience participation in the discussion of issues related to DK.
(For instance, DC-Cam will ask survivors to tell their stories on air next year.
We will also run a contest on the government-prepared booklet of questions and
answers on the tribunal; awards will be given to the first listeners to call in
with the correct answer.) Last, to increase the cost-effectiveness of our
production, we will open a new studio at DC-Cam in January 2005 that will enable
us to send pre-recorded tapes to local radio stations.
3.3
Website Development
We realize that our web page is often the
most readily available way for people to access our work. This is especially
true overseas, where many students and scholars, expatriate Khmers, and other
interested individuals read our magazine articles and other reports
electronically. Our website continued to increase its readership in 2004 and we
also acquired more server space, allowing us to present more of our project
findings and exhibitions on-line.
This year, for example, we scanned and
captioned over 180 photographs donated to our Photo Archive project by former
Khmer Rouge and their families. They have been test posted and all of the
photographs will be loaded onto our website as soon as the book has been
published. We also recently added a search engine to our site, making it easier
for visitors to find documents. Last, we have begun the re-design of our website
to improve the organization of our information and make the site more
attractive.
In 2005, we will continue with our website
re-design. In addition, we plan to host a chat room that will contain links to
the news and other articles posted on our site, and provide a forum for
exchanges among students, the public and DC-Cam staff. Last, the Highest Council
for Islamic Religious Affairs Cambodia is now helping us to collect data (number
of people in villages, number of males/females, children attending school,
livelihood, economic conditions). We will use these data to develop a webite for
the Cham Muslim community.
3.4
Pre-Trial Outreach
The broader the public involvement, the more
the tribunal will be viewed as effective and responsive to the needs of the
Cambodian people. In 2004, we met with nearly 400 Cham Muslim leaders
(hakem) from all parts of the country, 32 Buddhist nuns, and members of
22 youth and student associations in order to engage them in the tribunal
process. These groups represent a variety of religious beliefs and ages. They
have been given an introduction to the tribunal and asked to reflect on its
importance and their participation.
For 2005, we plan to implement a number of new
projects with these groups. We have two projects with the Cham community. The
first concerns oral history. Through hakem, we have developed and
distributed 30 questionnaires to 336 Cham villages throughout the country asking
about the roots of the community and their experiences during the Khmer Rouge
regime. The second project aims to disseminate information about Chams – their
history, livelihoods, and other relevant aspects – through the development of an
website that will enable Chams to communicate with academics, the public, and
other Muslim communities worldwide. The nuns have planned to organize a march
for justice. They will also participate in a number of public forums hosted by
DC-Cam. The forums will bring together victims and perpetrators to discuss
sexual abuse during Democratic Kampuchea and its impacts today. The student
groups we met with have planned to go door-to-door in several areas of Cambodia
to explain the process, activities, and benefits of the tribunal to
citizens.
3.5
Living Documents
This two-year project would help ensure the
involvement of the regime’s victims in the tribunal by bringing representatives
of communes throughout Cambodia to attend a portion of a trial. Each
representative would then return to his or her village and engage other members
of the public in discussions on the proceedings. We would also publicize the
forums in neighboring villages that did not have a representative at the trials
so that their residents can attend. During the first year of the project,
approximately 200 people (in groups of about 30) from representative communes
will travel to Phnom Penh and attend a trial for one week. This process would be
repeated for each of the ensuing five trials, allowing about 1,200 people to
attend a trial during the three-year tribunal.
The project will also help build the
momentum for democracy in Cambodia by allowing participants to serve as
surrogate witnesses and “judges” at the tribunals; holding open, participatory
discussions; making people aware of their “right to know”; and beginning a
popular movement to demand more freedom of information. It will give the commune
representatives a turn in the public eye (speaking, leading discussions,
fielding questions), thus helping to build leaders for future commune and
village elections. We intend to strengthen this benefit by giving community
innovation and leadership training to emerging commune leaders.
3.6
Genocide Education
This two-year project will provide the
Cambodian government with materials and resources to improve the quality and
amount of high school education on Democratic Kampuchea. At present, all
information on the regime has been removed from textbooks for both political and
technical reasons. It is our belief that helping the younger generation learn
the history of their country’s genocide will encourage a more active civil
society in Cambodia, one that will work to prevent grave abuses of human rights
in the future. We will conduct brief surveys of the status of genocide education
in Cambodia, provide annotated bibliographies and materials for curriculum
development, and prepare a brief text, with photographs, on Democratic Kampuchea
suitable for 12th grade students. We also plan to utilize the expertise of the
US Memorial Holocaust Museum, Anne Frank Foundation and other facilities in
helping us prepare educational materials. Some of DC-Cam’s academic advisors
will also provide our staff with guidance on this project (e.g., David Chandler, Cambodia scholar and author of Voices from
S-21, among other works; Frank Chalk, former chair of the
Montreal Holocaust Memorial
Centre).
3.7
Cross-Border Cooperation
DC-Cam staff visited four countries this
year to provide advice and assistance to organizations whose work is similar to
ours:
-
Iraq, to assist NGOs, the Coalition
Provisional Authority and the Iraqi Governing Council to design a
documentation effort to uncover abuses of the former Ba’athist regime.
-
Thailand, to help the Human Rights
Education Institute of Burma design and implement a small documentation
project for minority-controlled portions of Burma.
-
Serbia, to advise the Humanitarian Law
Center in Belgrade on the creation of a network of documentation offices in
the former Yugoslav states.
-
Vietnam, to seek cooperation on a study on
Buddhism under Democratic Kampuchea.
We are now in the process of developing two
activities that will increase our cooperation with, and assistance to, similar
organizations overseas.
The Affinity Group. Several organizations overseas have
recognized the expertise and experience that DC-Cam possesses, particularly in
the areas of documentation and public outreach. Limited staff time and language
constraints have precluded our providing detailed assistance to such
organizations. Nonetheless, we will be submitting a proposal shortly to form an
“affinity group” of documentation centers from other parts of the world (e.g.,
former Yugoslavia, Burma) that would meet three or four times a year to share
information and techniques, and work together to address constraints shared by
its members. We would also call in international experts to help think through
solutions to some of the technical documentation problems the Affinity Group
wishes to work on.
Internships. In September, we met with representatives
of several non-government organizations that are advocating for human rights in
Burma (e.g., Burmese Women’s Union, Women’s Leagues of Burma, Shan Women’s
Action Network). In 2005, we plan to host two or more interns from these groups,
who will come to DC-Cam to learn about our documentation, public outreach, and
other activities.
4. Research, Publications,
and Translation
Through monographs, shorter papers, and our
monthly magazine, we work to uncover the history of the Khmer Rouge, interpret
the facts, and present an impartial account to our many readers in Cambodia and
abroad. We also attempt to foster meaningful public and academic debate in
Cambodia about issues related to DK. In 2004, DC-Cam stepped up its research and
publication activities; we plan to do so again in 2005 as the tribunal
approaches.
4.1
Magazine Project
Since 2000, our monthly magazine,
Searching for the Truth, has disseminated our work to the public and
facilitated discourse on issues related to the Khmer Rouge. From
January-September 2004, we published an issue in Khmer each month and an English
edition every three months (the English editions contain articles selected from
the Khmer issues). For example:
-
The documentation section:
confessions of victims at S-21, documents on trade and economy in DK, and
articles/lists of Khmer Rouge leaders and victims.
-
The history section: articles written
by staff describing the lives of cadres and victims during DK.
-
The legal section: articles on the
UN-government tribunal agreement and amendments to the KR law, aspects of
Cambodian law (e.g., arrest warrants), and legal issues/tribunals in East
Timor, former Yugoslavia, South Africa, Chechnya, and Sierra Leone.
-
The debate section: articles
concerned Kofi Anan’s speech at the UN, civil society’s appeal for
international standards, and Khieu Samphan’s denial of responsibility.
-
The family tracing section:
recollections of DK survivors and announcements from aggrieved individuals
looking for information on lost loved ones.
We also received personal stories, letters
of appreciation, and requests for information from readers. In recent months,
the number of requests for information on people who disappeared during the Lon
Nol or Khmer Rouge regimes has jumped from 1 or 2 per month to about 15. We are
also seeing a rise in the number of Cambodians abroad who are requesting help in
learning about the fate of their family members.
In addition, we assisted the government’s
Task Force for Cooperation with Foreign Legal Experts and Preparation of the
Proceedings for the Trial of Senior Khmer Rouge Leaders in distributing An
Introduction to the Khmer Rouge Trials, a booklet explaining the background,
purpose and structure of the Extraordinary Chambers. We distributed 4,078 copies
with the November issue of our magazine.
Since we began publishing Searching for
the Truth in January 2000, we have distributed over a half-million copies of
our Khmer issues nationwide. In 2004, as in earlier years, we published 7,000
copies of each issue per month; of these over 80% are distributed free of
charge, mostly in Cambodia. We have continued to work with LICADHO, PADEK,
Partners for Development, and TPO to distribute the magazine. Our field
researchers also carried copies to Cambodia’s villages and distributed them. Our
English edition run is 700 copies, which are sold at various locations in Phnom
Penh and Siem Reap.
The public’s interest in Searching for
the Truth is growing, but the number of copies published has not. We are now
exploring ways to increase our publication run to meet public demand. Should
funds become available in 2005, we hope to expand our print run to meet the
growing demand for our magazine.
We are now working with the Cham Muslim
community to plan the production of a quarterly magazine for 2005. We anticipate
that the magazine will be 60 pages in length and cover topics of interest to the
community. It will also contain a special section written in the Cham language,
which employs Arabic script.
4.2
Historical Research and Writing
Our Research Project aims to develop an
historical understanding of the DK era and to build the capacity of young
Cambodians to produce quality writing and research. We also publish the work of
international scholars who use DC-Cam documents as a basis for their research.
This project was initiated in 2001 and by
the end of 2003 had produced three research monographs. In 2004, we published
three more monographs:
-
Seven Candidates for
Prosecution by Stephen
Heder and Brian Tittemore. This study examines the responsibility of seven
senior officials (Nuon Chea, Ieng Sary, Khieu Samphan, Ta Mok, Kae Pok, Sou
Met and Meah Mut) for their roles in developing and implementing the policies
of the Khmer Rouge. This is the first comprehensive legal analysis of
available evidence against specific individuals for international crimes.
-
Reconciliation in Cambodia
by Suzannah Linton. This
book analyzes the results of a 2003 Searching for the Truth survey of
justice and reconciliation in Cambodia, and provides a context for Cambodia in
terms of similar efforts in such nations as South Africa, Argentina, Chile,
and Rwanda.
-
Stilled Lives: Photographs from the
Cambodian Genocide by
Wynne Cougill with Pivoine Pang, Chhayran Ra, and Sopheak Sim. This book
contains photographs and essays on the lives of 51 men and women who joined
the Khmer Rouge (see Section 1).
Four manuscripts are now being completed or
being edited for publication in 2005:
-
Tum Teav: A Study of a
Cambodian Literary Classic
by George Chigas III (PhD, University of
London’s School of Oriental and African Studies)
-
Terror from the
Southwest Zone
by Meng-Try
Ea (DC-Cam)
-
The Winds from The West:
Khmer Rouge Purges in Mondul Kiri
by Sara Colm (Human Rights Watch) with Sorya
Sim (DC-Cam)
-
The Cham Rebellion
by Osman Ysa
(DC-Cam).
We are also considering writing a second book
for our Photo Archive Project (see Section 1) or a book of recollections of
Cambodian landmine victims.
DC-Cam has also provided support to a number
of international authors who have recently published works on Cambodia under the
Khmer Rouge. These include:
-
Khay Chuth’s Comment J’ai Menti
aux Khmer Rouges (Paris: L’Harmattan, 2004)
-
Maud Sundqvist’s Why Did They Kill So
Many? (Swedish Committee for Vietnam, Laos and Cambodia, 2004)
-
Peter Macguire’s Facing Death
(Colombia University Press, 2004)
-
Henri Locard’s Pol Pot’s Little Book: The
Sayings of Angkar (Silkworm, 2004)
-
Philip Short’s Pol Pot: The History of a
Nightmare (John Murray, 2004)
-
Enos Slaughter’s Solath Sar (music
CD) (Seers Music, 2004)
-
Alex Hinton’s Why Did they Kill?
(University of California Press, 2004)
-
Ian Harris’ Cambodian Buddhism: History
and Practice (USA: University of Hawaii Press, 2004. This book will be
edited for a general audience and published as a DC-Cam monograph in late 2005
or early 2006)
-
John Ciociarcari’s guidebook on the Khmer
Rouge tribunal (2005).
4.3
Translations
In 2004, we continued to translate a number
of foreign-language works into Khmer for our Cambodian audiences. These are
published in our magazine, Cambodian newspapers, and as monographs. The
translations begun or completed in 2004 were:
§
Brother
Enemy by Nayan Chanda
(published in a local newspaper)
§
Anne Frank’s
Diary (published in a local
newspaper)
§
Reconciliation in
Cambodia by Suzannah Linton
(summary only)
§
Tum Teav: A Study of a
Cambodian Literary Classic
by
George Chigas III (in
translation)
§
Journey into
Light by Ronnie Yimsut
(currently in translation).
In 2005, we plan to complete the translation
of at least two books: Lucky Child by Luong Ung (Ms. Ung is the author of
First They Killed My Father) and When the War Was Over, by
journalist Elizabeth Becker.
4.4
Research Forum: Preserving the History of the Khmer Rouge Regime
In 2003, DC-Cam and the Khmer Writers
Association held an essay competition for DK survivors.
We asked survivors to submit narrative essays on their lives during the regime
or their thoughts on issues related to the Khmer Rouge. Of the 43 essays
submitted, 4 were given awards at a ceremony held on April 2, 2004. The winning
essay has been published in both Khmer and English issues of
Searching for
the Truth.
Following the success of the first contest,
we have embarked on a new round of the essay contest for the period April 17,
2004 to February 29, 2005. We announced this contest in April through Rasmei
Kampuchea and Searching for the Truth. Since then, six essays have
been submitted to the competition.
4.5
Outreach through the Media and Academic Forums
Media Exposure, Articles and Interviews.
To share our work and
engage our staff members in public debate in Cambodia and abroad, we have long
endeavored to respond to any media interest in our work and to grant interviews
whenever possible. Our director, staff members, and advisors have also
contributed regularly to public discourse and education through frequent
articles in the local and international media. In the first nine months of 2004,
at least 230 articles were published by or about DC-Cam. They appeared in both
local (Cambodge Soir, Cambodia Daily, Cambodia Today, Koh Santepheap,
Oudomkate Khmer, Phnom Penh Post, and Rasmei Kampuchea Daily) and
international (ABA Radio Australia, AFP, AP, Bangkok Post, CBC
News, Chicago Tribune, Christian Science Monitor, Dallas Morning News,
Dow Jones Newswire, Financial Times, Kyodo, Le Monde, Long Beach Press
Telegram, The Nation, The New York Times, Newsweek, San Francisco Chronicle,
Toronto Star, and VOA) publications.
In addition, a number of our staff have
appeared on or been the subject of radio and television programs this year. For
example, Director Youk Chhang appeared on CNN and National Public Radio, while
staff members Tola Norng and Savina Sirik were profiled on the Árte French
television program Capte Absolute.
Public Lectures, Conferences and Seminars.
We worked in 2004 to
increase our public education output by sending staff members to deliver papers
at numerous conferences. Those events give us a chance to share our work and our
staff an opportunity to develop skills in writing and public speaking. In
addition, our PIR holds seminars and lectures each month for students and
members of the public about various aspects of Khmer Rouge history and related
issues. We plan to continue, and if possible, increase, these activities in
2005.
Selected
Lectures, Seminars and Conferences
Phnom Penh
in 2004 |
Selected
Lectures, Seminars and Conferences
Overseas
in 2004 |
§
Screening
and discussions on the film
S-21: The
Khmer Rouge Killing Machine,
Royal University
§
Roundtable on building the case
against senior
Khmer Rouge leaders,
Club of Cambodian
Journalists
§
Presentations on the Khmer Rouge
tribunal
to factory workers, Khmer
Youth
Organization
§
Paper on the history of the Khmer
Rouge and the legacy
of conflict,
Pannasastra University
§
Presentation on justice and
reconciliation
in Cambodia,
Cambodian
Youth Learning
Community
§
Presentation on how to work with
former
Khmer Rouge cadres, German
Development
Service
§
Papers on
cataloguing and
documenting the
Khmer
Rouge, PACT |
§
Screening
and discussions on the film
S-21: The
Khmer Rouge Killing Machine,
United Nations headquarters, New
York
§
Lectures on KR history, the roles of
victims
in the tribunal, and DC-Cam’s
Living
Documents project at 6
locations
in Canada
§
Papers on
reconciliation and justice:
Conference
on Issues and Challenges for Peace and Reconciliation in Southeast
Asia
§
Training on international
investigations,
Institute for Criminal
Investigations,
the Netherlands
§
Presentation
on the role of history in
preventing
the return of genocide, International Conference on Human Security,
Bangkok
§
Paper on political transitions and
justice
in Cambodia, Danish Holocaust
Institute
§
Paper on
the Cham Muslims during
DK, Kebangsaan
University, Malaysia
§
Paper on the Internet in Cambodia,
Kuala Lumpur,
Malaysia
§
Presentation on documentation of
genocide,
Dealing with the Past in ex-
Yugoslavia, Belgrade
|
5. Personnel
and Resource Development
We have made much progress on sending our
staff abroad for education this year, as well as recruiting new staff. DC-Cam
has also greatly enlarged its space. We plan to continue improving the size and
quality of both our staff and facilities in 2005, and to acquire a permanent
center.
5.1
Personnel
Staff Development/Study Abroad.
We have long believed that
continual staff development is essential if we are to maximize the efficiency
and quality of our work. Foreign study has been one of the most important means
of increasing our employees’ skills, exposing them to new ideas and approaches,
and enabling them to disseminate our work abroad. In 2004, we have seven staff
members studying for advanced degrees abroad:
-
-
-
-
Kosal Phat: PhD, international relations,
Southern California University (USA)
-
Sayana Ser: MA, tourism and museum studies
(Netherlands)
-
Bunsou P. Sour: LLM, Essex
University (UK)
-
Dara Vanthan: LLM, human rights law,
University of Notre Dame (USA).
In addition, staff member Dany Long began
working on a graduate diploma in development studies in Vietnam and Switzerland
at the Asian Institute of Technology. In Phnom Penh, Ysa Osman is continuing his
work toward a BA in English.
Volunteers.
For the past ten years, our center has
benefited from the services of Cambodian and foreign interns and volunteers.
Every member of our staff begun as a volunteer for a period of several months,
and we continue that tradition to ensure that staff members are deeply committed
to our cause. In 2004, we hosted seven new Cambodian volunteers: three are
working for our Victims of Torture Project, two for our monthly magazine, and
two for our PIR. We also four international volunteers: three legal experts and
a website/Internet expert.
In 2005, we plan to recruit at least six
Cambodian volunteers to work at the Center, particularly to supplement our
translation and data entry capabilities. We will canvass in Cambodia’s poorest
provinces to give students there an opportunity to volunteer, and eventually be
employed, at DC-Cam. We will also recruit volunteers from abroad (in November,
for example, we will visit the Harvard Law School job fair to find instructors
for our next legal training course).
Translation Capacity. Because our most experienced translation
staff are on academic leave, our capacity in this area has been greatly
diminished. As a result, we have recruited two volunteers for translation, but
will need additional volunteers and/or staff as the tribunal nears. Finding
skilled and experienced translators will remain a constraint to our work, as
such capacity is limited in Cambodia.
Visiting Scholars and Researchers.
We have hosted five
visiting scholars in 2004, each for a period of weeks or
months:
-
Dr. Stephen Heder, University of London
(UK)
-
Dr. Ian Harris, Oxford University
(UK)
-
Professor Elizabeth Van Schaack, Santa
Clara University School of Law (US)
-
Professor Ronald Slye, Seattle University
School of Law (US)
-
Professor Noah Novogrodsay, University of
Toronto Law School (Canada)
-
Bernie O’Donnell, senior prosecutor, ICTY,
Institute for Criminal Investigations.
5.2
Facilities and Resources
In 2004, we greatly extend our space by
renting a building immediately adjacent to our existing facility. It now serves
as our Public Information Room (see Section 2.4). In addition, we have taken
measures to enhance our security and find a professional fundraiser. By year-end
2005, we hope to find land and a building that will house a permanent
center.
Security.
As the prospective Khmer Rouge tribunal
approaches, we have reviewed and modestly enhanced the security of our staff and
documentary holdings. Our advisors and others have helped build our awareness of
possible security concerns (for example, we were recently apprised of indirect
threats being made in Kampong Thom province toward the Center’s director). We
have sent back-up copies of approximately 70% of our documents to universities
in the United States as a precaution against security threats that may come with
the tribunal. Nevertheless, we have not taken all of the precautions that we
will need in advance of the tribunal, and this remains a clear area for further
reflection and resource allocation.
Fundraising.
After a long search, we have
now identified a prospective consultant for fundraising. Negotiations are
underway with a donor to fund this service. Having a permanent fundraiser will
free up our management’s time for other activities.
Permanent
Center. We are committed to
the creation of a permanent center that will meet the long-term demands for our
work, and will give us better security, a library and exhibition hall, proper
storage facilities, and increased office space. Some time ago, we were given a
plot of land by the Cambodian government adjacent to the Tuol Sleng Genocide
Museum. But the land is now occupied by hundreds of squatters. As an
organization dedicated to the welfare of all Cambodians, we do not wish to
initiate legal proceedings for eviction. We have asked the Cambodian government
to provide us with a parcel of land in another location, and have also affirmed
our offers of assistance to help restore and upgrade the Tuol Sleng
Museum.
In 2004, we stepped up
our search for a suitable location. Although we have found one that is ideal, we
will not know before the end of the year if our bid was accepted. If our bid
fails, we will renew our search in 2005.
6.
Monitoring and
Evaluation Plan (with Project Timelines)
During DC-Cam’s annual work plan meeting in
September 2004, our staff reported on their achievements and the challenges they
faced in the past year, and made suggestions on how their work might be
improved. After consulting with the board of advisors and other experts, if the
director approved the suggestions, staff were re-allocated to meet the changed
workloads. Then, each staff member produced a calendar that showed the time he
or she was to devote to specific tasks each day during 2005. The team leaders
for each project then produced a project plan that is used to evaluate how a
project is being implemented. It includes a timeline, indictors, and impacts.
During 2005, we will hold weekly staff
meetings at which the office manager and team leaders will review each staff
member’s weekly report against the plan. Problems will be discussed and
corrective actions determined during the meeting. These reports will provide the
input for monthly reports for each project, as well as quarterly reports on
selected projects. In addition, they will be reviewed by project managers, the
office manager, the deputy directors, and the director, and course
corrections/staff reallocations made in order to meet deadlines and resolve
quality issues. These weekly, monthly and quarterly reviews enable us to meet
staff demands for our projects and keep them on track.
In addition, some of our projects require
evaluation assistance from outside experts. For example, our Victims of Torture
Project will call in psychologists and other professionals to assist us in
improving our outputs because we do not possess the requisite in-house
expertise. In addition, to ensure the quality and accuracy of our work, we
always request reviews by historians, international law professors, and others
before we publish a monograph.
The remainder of this section first shows
the progress we plan to make in 2005 against the goals we set for our major
activities. This is followed by an indication of the number of staff to be
devoted to each task and a discussion of the procedures we will use to monitor
and evaluate our progress.
6.1
Documentation
Activity |
Q1 |
Q2 |
Q3 |
Q4 |
Goal by
9/2005 |
D
Catalogued |
8,454 |
Complete |
Complete |
Complete |
8,454 |
R
Catalogued |
528 |
528 |
528 |
528 |
2,112 |
D Khmer
Keyed |
3,575 |
3,363 |
3,249 |
3,249 |
9,861 |
D English
Keyed |
4,320 |
4,320 |
4,464 |
4,464 |
17,568 |
Index
Book |
250 |
240 |
240 |
240 |
970 |
Access
Listing |
1,140 |
1,140 |
1,100 |
1,200 |
4,580 |
R
Microfilmed |
5,254 |
Complete |
Complete |
Complete |
5,254 |
PA
Microfilmed |
-- |
21,120 |
21,120 |
Complete |
40,000+ |
Staff: 8 full-time, 1 part-time
Cataloging, Keying, and
Indexing. These are fairly
straightforward activities to monitor and evaluate, and because we have been
doing this work for several years, our staff are very practiced in this regard.
Each member of our documentation staff has a set number of documents he or she
is to catalog or key, and their progress is monitored weekly. We will evaluate
our success using the number of documents we project to be completed.
Database/Server Management. This activity was slower than expected last
year because we were unable to find sufficient technical expertise within
Cambodia. We have now contacted a new IT expert to design the database. In
addition, the company we originally hired for this task is still working on a
solution. We will purchase the database from whomever produces the best design
(no money will be paid until the product is in our hands). Having set up this
“competition,” the database should be completed by June 2005.
Microfilming.
We have assigned an individual with 10 years
of professional experience to work on microfilming. During two weeks in
December, he developed 8 reels (5,799 pages), completing our R collection. At
this rate, he will easily complete 18,000 pages a month and complete the
microfilming of our PA documents before the end of the third quarter.
6.2
Promoting Accountability and the Rule of Law
Activity |
Q1 |
Q2 |
Q3 |
Q4 |
Goal by
9/2005 |
Survivors
Interviewed |
81 |
187 |
180 |
201 |
669 |
Interview
Pages |
1,812 |
2,800 |
2,660 |
5,040 |
12,312 |
Visitors
to PIR |
456 |
500 |
500 |
500 |
1,956 |
Staff: 8 full-time
PA Project.
We have actual results for Quarter 1
(October-December 2004). They are lower than expected because our team was in
the field re-interviewing former cadres; this was done at the request of one of
the experts we consulted on this project, who was conducting a legal analysis of
the interviews and other data we had collected. For all of 2004, our teams
conducted 476 interviews (an average of 118 per month). However, as our teams
become more experienced and planning improves, we anticipate we can conduct
about 167 interviews per month.
When our PA staff are in the field (11 weeks
a quarter, with a one-week break in Phnom Penh), they will report to the office
manager by email every Saturday. Their reports include the number of people they
interviewed and their status (e.g., alive, disappeared), and a summary of each
interviewee’s account and our team’s observations. Our director reviews the
reports daily and gives the team members direct feedback on their progress. In
addition, our Harvard/Oxford-trained legal advisor and our advisor from the
University of London will regularly evaluate the reports and overall progress of
the project.
Public Information Room Visitors
(Staff: 4, of which 3 are
volunteers). In 2004, we hosted an average of 325 visitors per quarter. This
year, we anticipate about 500 visitors per quarter. Our director will work with
our PIR manager to devise new activities of interest to the public. We note,
however, that if the tribunal is not held in 2005, there may be additional
public interest in learning why trials did not occur, and the PIR can play a
role in informing the public on this and other issues.
Activity |
Q1 |
Q2 |
Q3 |
Q4 |
Goal by
9/2005 |
Film
show |
24 |
24 |
24 |
24 |
96 |
Public
lecture |
3 |
3 |
3 |
3 |
12 |
Library
(visitors) |
456 |
500 |
500 |
500 |
1,956 |
6.3
Public Education and Outreach
Activity |
Q1 |
Q2 |
Q3 |
Q4 |
Goal by
9/2005 |
VOT
Interviews |
52 |
48 |
38 |
40 |
178 |
VOT
Interview pages |
1,750 |
2,230 |
2,415 |
1,875 |
8,270 |
Victims of Torture Project
(Staff: 5 full-time). Last year,
DC-Cam was able to interview 49 people per quarter; for 2005, we plan to
interview slightly less people (44-45 per quarter). This is because we have
reduced the number of staff working on the VOT Project, but will be able to meet
its interview quota by the end of the project. In addition, it appears that
demand for the project’s services (counseling and other treatment) will likely
outstrip TPO’s ability to provide it.
As noted above, TPO and DC-Cam plan to bring
additional experts from overseas to evaluate and make recommendations on our
project in early 2005.
Activity |
Q1 |
Q2 |
Q3 |
Q4 |
Goal by
9/2005 |
Radio time
coverage (h) |
186.45 |
276.45 |
366.45 |
456.45 |
1,287 |
Radio area
coverage (city/province) |
9 |
14 |
17 |
19 |
19 |
Radio
content coverage |
37 |
70 |
77 |
84 |
268 |
Radio
(Staff: 2 part-time, who are part of our
magazine project staff). This year, we plan to expand our coverage to at least
two additional provinces. We will monitor the effectiveness of our programming
using feedback staff obtain while they are on field trips and letters to the
editor of our monthly magazine.
Website
(Staff: 1 full-time). Our director
will regularly supervise postings on the website. One of our advisors and a
volunteer have begun the website re-design, which we anticipate will be
completed by mid-2005. We will be able to evaluate its effectiveness via 1)
visitors to the site, 2) visitors to a planned chatroom, and 3) comments
received through our magazine and other vehicles. At present, the number of
visitors to our site is approximately 30 per day.
Pre-trial
Outreach (Staff: 1
full-time, assisted by 2 staff from the Magazine and PA teams). The success of
the trial will depend to a great degree on how many people know about it or
respond to it. We have begun outreach work with three special groups (Cham
Muslims, Buddhist nuns, and students) who we hope will be able to understand,
voice concern, contribute to, and observe or participate actively in the
tribunal process.
The project
will be evaluated at each step by DC-Cam’s team leaders, deputy directors, and
director. The means of evaluating our success in this project will include the
number of participants at meetings, the number responding to our questionnaires,
field visits undertaken to collect completed questionnaires (Cham), surveys
collected by youth groups, participants in a planned peace march (nuns), and
press coverage and feedback from the public.
Genocide Education (Staff: 1 full-time, 1 part-time). This
project began in September 2004; the first year will be devoted to the gathering
and preparation of materials before the book is written. The progress on this
project will be reviewed by Professor David Chandler, one of the leading
scholars of Cambodian history. His first trip to Cambodia to work on this
project is scheduled for late January.
Cross-border Cooperation (Staff: 2 part-time). DC-Cam will host the
first meeting of an Affinity Group of similar documentation centers in March.
Formal evaluations of this project will be conducted by its members (currently,
from ICTJ, Burma, Guatemala, Serbia, and Iraq) as well as a number of outside
experts who will be asked to comment on its progress.
In addition, we plan to host at least two
interns from Burma this year, should their organizations give them leave. We
will also have three to six interns from North America working on our Legal
Training Project. We will ask them to evaluate their experience at
DC-Cam.
6.4
Research, Publication, and Translation
Searching for
the Truth
Activity |
Q1 |
Q2 |
Q3 |
Q4 |
Goal by
9/2005 |
Number of
print-run
Free
distribution
Sale |
23,100
22,500
600 |
23,100
22,500
600+ |
23,100
22,500
600+ |
23,100
22,500
600+ |
92,400
90,000
2,400+ |
Numbers of
articles/announcements published |
39 |
39+ |
39+ |
39+ |
156+ |
Number of
family tracing/letters/requests to editor received |
22 |
22+ |
22+ |
22+ |
88+ |
Staff: 7 full-time, including 1
volunteer
The director, deputy directors, and team
leaders will review and oversee the contents and quality of our magazine
articles. Our main method of evaluating our success will come from our readers:
increased numbers of letters to editors, feedback (through staff on provincial
trips), follow-up letters/calls with the provincial and local authorities, etc.
Research and Translation
(Staff: 2 full-time, plus seconded other
staff). Last year, we were able to double the number of monographs we wrote and
published. This year, we plan to meet or exceed that goal, in addition to
publishing two translations. Our monographs are peer-reviewed and if possible,
reviewed by historians and other experts prior to publication as a means of
evaluating their quality.
7.
Conclusions
Fulfilling our plans for 2005 will help us
move closer to accomplishing our core objectives. With the continued generosity
of our donors and our support from the Royal Cambodian Government (especially
the Ministry of Interior for security and access), we are confident that we will
be able to do so. Over time, the role that we play in Cambodian and
international society has grown, and so has our responsibility. Both at home and
abroad, during the prospective Khmer Rouge tribunal and beyond, we will continue
to contribute in whatever way possible to the search for truth, accountability,
and the rule of law.
We at DC-Cam very much welcome your thoughts
on our 2005 work plan. Please do not hesitate to contact us at [855] 23-211-875
or via email at dccam@online.com.kh if you have any
questions or comments. We appreciate your interest in the Center and look
forward to your continued support of memory, justice, and reconciliation in
Cambodia.
Memorandum prepared by DC-Cam deputy
director Sorya Sim and advisor Wynne Cougill
November 22, 2004 (updated January 13,
2005)
cc:
Professor Heng Vanda, Chair
Youk Chhang,
Director
Dara P. Vanthan,
Deputy
Irene Sokha,
Deputy
Although DC-Cam is not alone
in encouraging the ratification, we feel that our advocacy of finding justice
for the Cambodian people had some part in this process. In addition, in July
2004, we sent a request to the government proposing that it declare a national
Day of Remembrance and Justice, which would be held on the first day of the
tribunal. This holiday would allow Cambodians to honor the loved ones they lost
during the regime, and survivors to remember share their experiences with
others. We are pleased to note that on October 5, 2005, Prime Minister
Hun Sen announced that Cambodia will adopt this national holiday.
|
|